List of Ontario by-elections
The list of Ontario by-elections includes every by-election held in the Canadian province of Ontario. By-elections occur whenever there is a vacancy in the Legislative Assembly, although an imminent general election may allow the vacancy to remain until the dissolution of parliament.
Causes
A by-election occurs whenever there is a vacancy in the Ontario legislature. Vacancies can occur for the following reasons:
- Death of a member.
- Resignation of a member.
- Voided results
- Expulsion from the legislature.
- Ineligibility to sit.
When there is a vacancy, a by-election must be called within six months. Under amendments to the Election Act approved in 2016, a by-election is no longer required when a vacancy occurs in the 12 months leading up to a fixed general election date.
Ministerial by-elections
The list includes ministerial by-elections which occurred due to the requirement that incumbent members recontest their seats upon being appointed to Cabinet. These by-elections were almost always uncontested. This requirement was amended in 1926 to exempt ministers appointed within three months after a general election. In 1941 it was abolished completely.
42nd Legislative Assembly of Ontario 2018–present
By-election | Date | Incumbent | Party | Winner | Party | Cause | Retained | ||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Ottawa—Vanier | February 27, 2020 | Nathalie Des Rosiers | Liberal | Lucille Collard | Liberal | Resigned to become Principal of Massey College | Yes | ||
Orléans | February 27, 2020 | Marie-France Lalonde | Liberal | Stephen Blais | Liberal | Resigned to enter federal politics | Yes |
41st Legislative Assembly of Ontario 2014–2018
By-election | Date | Incumbent | Party | Winner | Party | Cause | Retained | ||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Sault Ste. Marie | June 1, 2017 | David Orazietti | Liberal | Ross Romano | Progressive Conservative | Resignation. | No | ||
Niagara West—Glanbrook | November 17, 2016 | Tim Hudak | Progressive Conservative | Sam Oosterhoff | Progressive Conservative | Resignation to become CEO of Ontario Real Estate Association. | Yes | ||
Ottawa—Vanier | November 17, 2016 | Madeleine Meilleur | Liberal | Nathalie Des Rosiers | Liberal | Resignation. | Yes | ||
Scarborough—Rouge River | September 1, 2016 | Bas Balkissoon | Liberal | Raymond Cho | Progressive Conservative | Resignation. | No | ||
Whitby—Oshawa | February 11, 2016 | Christine Elliott | Progressive Conservative | Lorne Coe | Progressive Conservative | Resigned after losing leadership contest. | Yes | ||
Simcoe North | September 3, 2015 | Garfield Dunlop | Progressive Conservative | Patrick Brown | Progressive Conservative | Resignation to create a vacancy for PC leader Brown. | Yes | ||
Sudbury | February 5, 2015 | Joe Cimino | New Democratic | Glenn Thibeault | Liberal | Resignation. | No |
40th Legislative Assembly of Ontario 2011–2014
39th Legislative Assembly of Ontario 2007–2011
By-election | Date | Incumbent | Party | Winner | Party | Cause | Retained | ||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Ottawa West—Nepean | March 4, 2010 | Jim Watson | Liberal | Bob Chiarelli | Liberal | Resignation to run for Mayor of Ottawa | Yes | ||
Leeds—Grenville | March 4, 2010 | Robert Runciman | Progressive Conservative | Steve Clark | Progressive Conservative | Resignation upon appointment to Canadian Senate. | Yes | ||
Toronto Centre | February 4, 2010 | George Smitherman | Liberal | Glen Murray | Liberal | Resignation to run for Mayor of Toronto. | Yes | ||
St. Paul's | September 17, 2009 | Michael Bryant | Liberal | Eric Hoskins | Liberal | Resignation to accept municipal appointment. | Yes | ||
Haliburton—Kawartha Lakes—Brock | March 5, 2009 | Laurie Scott | Progressive Conservative | Rick Johnson | Liberal | Resignation to create vacancy for PC leader John Tory. | No |
38th Legislative Assembly of Ontario 2003–2007
37th Legislative Assembly of Ontario 1999–2003
By-election | Date | Incumbent | Party | Winner | Party | Cause | Retained | ||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Dufferin—Peel—Wellington—Grey | May 2, 2002 | David Tilson | Progressive Conservative | Ernie Eves | Progressive Conservative | Resignation to create vacancy for PC leader and Premier Ernie Eves. | Yes | ||
Nipissing | May 2, 2002 | Mike Harris | Progressive Conservative | Al McDonald | Progressive Conservative | Resignation after retiring as Premier and party leader. | Yes | ||
Beaches-East York | September 20, 2001 | Frances Lankin | New Democratic | Michael Prue | New Democratic | Resignation to become CEO of United Way Toronto | Yes | ||
Vaughan—King—Aurora | June 28, 2001 | Al Palladini | Progressive Conservative | Greg Sorbara | Liberal | Death | No | ||
Parry Sound—Muskoka | March 22, 2001 | Ernie Eves | Progressive Conservative | Norm Miller | Progressive Conservative | Resignation | Yes | ||
Wentworth-Burlington | September 7, 2000 | Toni Skarica | Progressive Conservative | Ted McMeekin | Liberal | Resignation to protest municipal amalgamation. | No |
36th Legislative Assembly of Ontario 1995–1999
By-election | Date | Incumbent | Party | Winner | Party | Cause | Retained | ||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Nickel Belt | October 1, 1998 | Floyd Laughren | New Democratic | Blain Morin | New Democratic | Resignation to accept appointment as chair of Ontario Energy Board | Yes | ||
Oriole | September 4, 1997 | Elinor Caplan | Liberal | David Caplan | Liberal | Resignation to enter federal politics | Yes | ||
Ottawa West | September 4, 1997 | Bob Chiarelli | Liberal | Alex Cullen | Liberal | Resignation to run municipally | Yes | ||
Windsor—Riverside | September 4, 1997 | Dave Cooke | New Democratic | Wayne Lessard | New Democratic | Resignation to accept provincial appointment to the Education Improvement Commission. | Yes | ||
York South | May 23, 1996 | Bob Rae | New Democratic | Gerard Kennedy | Liberal | Resignation. | No |
35th Legislative Assembly of Ontario 1990–1995
By-election | Date | Incumbent | Party | Winner | Party | Cause | Retained | ||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Victoria—Haliburton | March 17, 1994 | Dennis Drainville | Independent | Chris Hodgson | Progressive Conservative | Resignation to run federally. | No | ||
Essex South | December 2, 1993 | Remo Mancini | Liberal | Bruce Crozier | Liberal | Resignation | Yes | ||
St. George—St. David | April 1, 1993 | Ian Scott | Liberal | Tim Murphy | Liberal | Resignation | Yes | ||
Don Mills | April 1, 1993 | Margery Ward | New Democratic | David Johnson | Progressive Conservative | Death | No | ||
Brant—Haldimand | March 5, 1992 | Robert Nixon | Liberal | Ronald Eddy | Liberal | Resignation to accept federal appointment. | Yes |
34th Legislative Assembly of Ontario 1987–1990
By-election | Date | Incumbent | Party | Winner | Party | Cause | Retained | ||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Welland—Thorold | November 3, 1988 | Mel Swart | New Democratic | Peter Kormos | New Democratic | Resignation. | Yes | ||
London North | March 31, 1988 | Ron Van Horne | Liberal | Dianne Cunningham | Progressive Conservative | Resignation. | No |
33rd Legislative Assembly of Ontario 1985–1987
By-election | Date | Incumbent | Party | Winner | Party | Cause | Retained | ||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Cochrane North | August 14, 1986 | René Fontaine | Liberal | René Fontaine | Liberal | Resignation from cabinet and legislature to resubmit candidacy to voters after it was revealed he had forgotten to disclose his ownership of shares in a mining company contrary to conflict of interest guidelines. | Yes | ||
York East | April 17, 1986 | Robert Elgie | Progressive Conservative | Christine Hart | Liberal | Resignation to accept appointment as head of Workers Compensation Board. | No |
32nd Legislative Assembly of Ontario 1981–1985
By-election | Date | Incumbent | Party | Winner | Party | Cause | Retained | ||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Wentworth North | December 13, 1984 | Eric Cunningham | Liberal | Ann Sloat | Progressive Conservative | Resignation to run federally. | No | ||
Prescott and Russell | December 13, 1984 | Don Boudria | Liberal | Jean Poirier | Liberal | Resignation to run federally. | Yes | ||
Ottawa East | December 13, 1984 | Albert J. Roy | Liberal | Bernard Grandmaître | Liberal | Resignation to run federally. | Yes | ||
Ottawa Centre | December 13, 1984 | Michael Cassidy | New Democratic | Evelyn Gigantes | New Democratic | Resignation to run federally. | Yes | ||
Hamilton Centre | December 13, 1984 | Sheila Copps | Liberal | Mike Davison | New Democratic | Resignation to run federally. | No | ||
Stormont—Dundas—Glengarry | December 15, 1983 | Osie Villeneuve | Progressive Conservative | Noble Villeneuve | Progressive Conservative | Death | Yes | ||
York South | November 4, 1982 | Donald C. MacDonald | New Democratic | Bob Rae | New Democratic | Resignation to create vacancy for NDP leader Bob Rae. | Yes | ||
Hamilton West | June 17, 1982 | Stuart Smith | Liberal | Richard Allen | New Democratic | Resignation from legislature after his successor as Liberal leader was chosen. | No |
31st Legislative Assembly of Ontario 1977–1981
By-election | Date | Incumbent | Party | Winner | Party | Cause | Retained | ||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Carleton | November 20, 1980 | Sid Handleman | Progressive Conservative | Robert C. Mitchell | Progressive Conservative | Resignation | Yes | ||
Scarborough West | April 5, 1979 | Stephen Lewis | New Democratic | Richard Johnston | New Democratic | Resignation several months after his successor as Ontario NDP leader was chosen. | Yes | ||
Wentworth | April 5, 1979 | Ian Deans | New Democratic | Colin Isaacs | New Democratic | Resignation after being defeated in his candidacy to lead the Ontario NDP. | Yes | ||
Sault Ste. Marie | December 14, 1978 | John Rhodes | Progressive Conservative | Russ Ramsay | Progressive Conservative | Death. | Yes | ||
Chatham—Kent | October 19, 1978 | Darcy McKeough | Progressive Conservative | Andrew Naismith Watson | Progressive Conservative | Resignation. | Yes |
30th Legislative Assembly of Ontario 1975–1977
no by-elections
29th Legislative Assembly of Ontario 1971–1975
By-election | Date | Incumbent | Party | Winner | Party | Cause | Retained | ||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Carleton East | November 7, 1974 | Bert Lawrence | Progressive Conservative | Paul Frederick Taylor | Liberal | Resignation. | No | ||
Stormont | October 17, 1974 | Fernand Guindon | Progressive Conservative | George Samis | New Democratic | Resignation to run federally. | No | ||
Huron | March 15, 1973 | Charles MacNaughton | Progressive Conservative | Jack Riddell | Liberal | Resignation. | No | ||
St. George | March 15, 1973 | Allan Lawrence | Progressive Conservative | Margaret Campbell | Liberal | Resignation to enter federal politics. | No |
28th Legislative Assembly of Ontario 1967–1971
By-election | Date | Incumbent | Party | Winner | Party | Cause | Retained | ||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Middlesex South | September 18, 1969 | Neil Leverne Olde | Progressive Conservative | Kenneth Charles Bolton | New Democratic | Death. | No |
27th Legislative Assembly of Ontario 1963–1967
By-election | Date | Incumbent | Party | Winner | Party | Cause | Retained | ||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Kenora | September 22, 1966 | Robert Wayne Gibson | Liberal-Labour | Leo Bernier | Progressive Conservative | Death | No | ||
Nipissing | September 15, 1965 | Leo Troy | Liberal | Richard Smith | Liberal | Death | Yes | ||
Bracondale | September 15, 1965 | Joseph M. Gould | Liberal | George Ben | Liberal | Death | Yes | ||
Riverdale | September 10, 1964 | Robert Macaulay | Progressive Conservative | Jim Renwick | New Democratic | Resigned to return to private live | No | ||
Windsor—Sandwich | September 10, 1964 | Maurice Belanger | Liberal | Ivan Thrasher | Progressive Conservative | Death[1] | No |
26th Legislative Assembly of Ontario 1959–1963
By-election | Date | Incumbent | Party | Winner | Party | Cause | Retained | ||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Huron—Bruce | October 4, 1962 | John William Hanna | Progressive Conservative | Murray Gaunt | Liberal | Death | No | ||
Beaches | January 18, 1962 | William Henry Collings | Progressive Conservative | Robert John Harris | Progressive Conservative | Death | Yes | ||
Brant | January 18, 1962 | Harry Nixon | Liberal | Robert Nixon | Liberal | Death | Yes | ||
Eglinton | January 18, 1962 | William James Dunlop | Progressive Conservative | Leonard Mackenzie Reilly | Progressive Conservative | Death | Yes | ||
Kenora | January 18, 1962 | Albert Wren | Liberal-Labour | Robert Wayne Gibson | Liberal | Death | Yes | ||
Renfrew South | January 18, 1962 | James Anthony Maloney | Progressive Conservative | Leonard Joseph Quilty | Liberal | Death | No | ||
Simcoe Centre | September 29, 1960 | George Graham Johnston | Progressive Conservative | David Arthur Evans | Progressive Conservative | Death | Yes | ||
Timiskaming | September 29, 1960 | Alexander Robert Herbert | Progressive Conservative | Phillip Hoffman | Progressive Conservative | Death | Yes |
25th Legislative Assembly of Ontario 1955–1959
† Won by acclamation
24th Legislative Assembly of Ontario 1951–1955
By-election | Date | Incumbent | Party | Winner | Party | Cause | Retained | ||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Leeds | September 16, 1954 | Charles Gordon MacOdrum | Progressive Conservative | James Auld | Progressive Conservative | Death | Yes | ||
Nipissing | September 16, 1954 | William Bruce Harvey | Progressive Conservative | Jean Marc Chaput | Progressive Conservative | Death | Yes | ||
Russell | September 16, 1954 | Joseph Daniel Nault | Progressive Conservative | Gordon Lavergne | Progressive Conservative | Death | Yes | ||
Simcoe East | February 8, 1954 | John Duncan McPhee | Progressive Conservative | Lloyd Averall Letherby | Progressive Conservative | Death | Yes | ||
Niagara Falls | October 26, 1953 | William Houck | Liberal | Arthur Connaught Jolley | Progressive Conservative | Resigned to enter federal politics | No |
23rd Legislative Assembly of Ontario 1948–1951
By-election | Date | Incumbent | Party | Winner | Party | Cause | Retained | ||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Leeds | October 31, 1949 | Walter Bain Reynolds | Progressive Conservative | Hugh Alexander Reynolds | Progressive Conservative | Death | Yes | ||
Cochrane North | June 8, 1949 | John Carrère | Progressive Conservative | Marcel Léger | Progressive Conservative | Death | Yes | ||
Parry Sound | December 9, 1948 | Charles Wilson Cragg | Progressive Conservative | Allister Johnston | Progressive Conservative | Death | Yes |
22nd Legislative Assembly of Ontario 1945–1948
By-election | Date | Incumbent | Party | Winner | Party | Cause | Retained | ||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Huron | February 16, 1948 | Robert Hobbs Taylor | Progressive Conservative | Thomas Pryde | Progressive Conservative | Death | Yes |
21st Legislative Assembly of Ontario 1943–1945
By-election | Date | Incumbent | Party | Winner | Party | Cause | Retained | ||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Haldimand—Norfolk | March 20, 1944 | Wallace William Walsh | Progressive Conservative | Charles Hammond Martin | Progressive Conservative | Death | Yes |
20th Legislative Assembly of Ontario 1937–1943
† Won by acclamation
*Though nominally an "Independent-Liberal", MacBride was a supporter of the Liberal government and was a cabinet minister at the time of his death
19th Legislative Assembly of Ontario 1934–1937
By-election | Date | Incumbent | Party | Winner | Party | Cause | Retained | ||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Hastings East | December 9, 1936 | James Ferguson Hill | Conservative | Harold Edward Welsh | Conservative | Death | Yes | ||
Nipissing | March 4, 1935 | Théodore Legault | Liberal | Joseph Marceau | Liberal | Death | Yes | ||
Grey North | August 20, 1934 | David James Taylor | Liberal-Progressive | Roland Patterson | Liberal-Progressive | Resigned to accept appointment as Deputy Minister of Game and Fisheries | Yes | ||
Wellington South | August 20, 1934 | Duncan Paul Munro | Liberal | James Harold King | Liberal | Death | Yes | ||
Kenora | August 7, 1934† | Earl Hutchinson | Labour | Peter Heenan | Liberal | Resigned to become vice-chairman of Workmen's Compensation Board | No |
† Won by acclamation
18th Legislative Assembly of Ontario 1929–1934
By-election | Date | Incumbent | Party | Winner | Party | Cause | Retained | ||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Kent East | January 3, 1934† | Philip James Henry | Conservative | Douglas Munro Campbell | Liberal | Death | No | ||
York West | May 28, 1932 | Forbes Godfrey | Conservative | Henry Isaac Price | Conservative | Death | Yes | ||
Wellington South | November 18, 1931 | Lincoln Goldie | Conservative | Duncan Paul Munro | Liberal | Died | No | ||
Dundas | August 29, 1931† | George Holmes Challies | Conservative | George Holmes Challies | Conservative | Sought re-election upon appointment as Provincial Secretary and Registrar | Yes | ||
Norfolk | July 8, 1931 | John Strickler Martin | Conservative | Arthur Campbell Burt | Conservative | Death | Yes | ||
Grenville | February 11, 1931 | Howard Ferguson | Conservative | James Alfred Sanderson | Conservative | Resigned to accept appointment as Canadian High Commissioner to the United Kingdom | Yes | ||
Hamilton West | February 11, 1931 | Frederick Thomas Smye | Conservative | D'Arcy Argue Counsell Martin | Conservative | Death | Yes | ||
Lanark South | October 29, 1930 | James Alexander Anderson | Conservative | Egerton Reuben Stedman | Conservative | Death | Yes | ||
Nipissing | October 29, 1930 | Henri Morel | Conservative | Charles Robert Harrison | Conservative | Resigned to run in the 1930 federal election | Yes | ||
Perth South | October 29, 1930 | David Bonis | Conservative | Charles Edward Richardson | Conservative | Death | Yes | ||
Waterloo South | October 29, 1930 | Karl Kenneth Homuth | Conservative | Norman Hipel | Liberal | Resigned to run in the 1930 federal election | No | ||
Algoma | October 18, 1930† | John Morrow Robb | Conservative | John Morrow Robb | Conservative | Sought re-election upon appointment as Minister of Health | Yes | ||
Brantford | October 18, 1930† | William George Martin | Conservative | William George Martin | Conservative | Sought re-election upon appointment as Minister of Public Welfare | Yes | ||
Peel | October 18, 1930† | Thomas Laird Kennedy | Conservative | Thomas Laird Kennedy | Conservative | Sought re-election upon appointment as Minister of Agriculture | Yes | ||
Renfrew North | October 18, 1930† | Edward Arunah Dunlop | Conservative | Edward Arunah Dunlop | Conservative | Sought re-election upon appointment as Provincial Treasurer | Yes | ||
York South | October 18, 1930† | Leopold Macaulay | Conservative | Leopold Macaulay | Conservative | Sought re-election upon appointment as Provincial Secretary and Registrar | Yes |
† Won by acclamation
17th Legislative Assembly of Ontario 1926–1929
By-election | Date | Incumbent | Party | Winner | Party | Cause | Retained | ||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Renfrew North | June 27, 1928 | Alexander Stuart | Conservative | Edward Arunah Dunlop | Conservative | Death | Yes | ||
Bruce South | June 27, 1928 | Malcolm Alex McCallum | Progressive | Foster Graham Moffatt | Conservative | Election declared void | No | ||
Hamilton East | June 27, 1928 | Leeming Carr | Conservative | William Robert Morrison | Conservative | Resigned to accept appointment as Sheriff of Wellington County | Yes | ||
Prince Edward | November 1, 1927† | William Raney | United Farmers of Ontario | Horace Stanley Colliver | Conservative | Appointed to Supreme Court of Ontario | No |
† Won by acclamation
16th Legislative Assembly of Ontario 1923–1926
By-election | Date | Incumbent | Party | Winner | Party | Cause | Retained | ||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Toronto Northwest A | July 7, 1924 | Thomas Crawford | Conservative | William Henry Edwards | Conservative | Resigned to accept appointment as Registrar | Yes | ||
Waterloo South | June 23, 1924 | Karl Kenneth Homuth | Labour | Karl Kenneth Homuth | Labour | Election declared void | Yes | ||
Lennox | October 22, 1923 | John Perry Vrooman | Liberal | Charles Wesley Hambly | Conservative | Death | No | ||
York West | August 16, 1923† | Forbes Godfrey | Conservative | Forbes Godfrey | Conservative | Sought re-election upon appointment as Minister of Labour | Yes | ||
York East | August 16, 1923† | George Stewart Henry | Conservative | George Stewart Henry | Conservative | Sought re-election upon appointment as Minister of Public Works and Highways | Yes | ||
Wellington South | August 16, 1923† | Lincoln Goldie | Conservative | Lincoln Goldie | Conservative | Sought re-election upon appointment as Provincial Secretary and Registrar | Yes | ||
Sudbury | August 16, 1923† | Charles McCrea | Conservative | Charles McCrea | Conservative | Sought re-election upon appointment as Minister of Mines | Yes | ||
Sault Ste. Marie | August 16, 1923† | James Winfield Lyons | Conservative | James Winfield Lyons | Conservative | Sought re-election upon appointment as Minister of Lands and Forests | Yes | ||
Parkdale | August 16, 1923† | William Herbert Price | Conservative | William Herbert Price | Conservative | Sought re-election upon appointment as Provincial Treasurer | Yes | ||
Norfolk South | August 16, 1923† | John Strickler Martin | Conservative | John Strickler Martin | Conservative | Sought re-election upon appointment as Minister of Agriculture | Yes | ||
Kingston | August 16, 1923† | William Folger Nickle | Conservative | William Folger Nickle | Conservative | Sought re-election upon appointment as Attorney-General | Yes | ||
Grenville | August 16, 1923† | George Howard Ferguson | Conservative | George Howard Ferguson | Conservative | Sought re-election upon appointment as Premier and Minister of Education | Yes |
† Won by acclamation
15th Legislative Assembly of Ontario 1919–1923
By-election | Date | Incumbent | Party | Winner | Party | Cause | Retained | ||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Russell | October 23, 1922 | Damase Racine | Liberal | Alfred Goulet | Liberal | Death | Yes | ||
Toronto Southeast A | October 23, 1922 | John O'Neill | Liberal | John Allister Currie | Conservative | Death | No | ||
Kingston | February 6, 1922 | Arthur Edward Ross | Conservative | William Folger Nickle | Conservative | Resigned to run in the 1921 federal election | Yes | ||
Oxford North | December 19, 1921 | John Alexander Calder | Liberal | David Munroe Ross | United Farmers of Ontario | Death | No | ||
Toronto Northeast A | November 8, 1920 | Henry John Cody | Conservative | Alexander Cameron Lewis | Conservative | Resignation | Yes | ||
Fort William | July 19, 1920† | Harry Mills | Labour | Harry Mills | Labour | Sought re-election upon appointment as Minister of Mines | Yes | ||
Wellington East | February 23, 1920† | Albert Hellyer | United Farmers of Ontario | William Raney | United Farmers of Ontario | Resignation to provide a seat for Raney | Yes | ||
Halton | February 16, 1920 | John Featherstone Ford | United Farmers of Ontario | Ernest Charles Drury | United Farmers of Ontario | Resignation to provide a seat for Drury | Yes | ||
Kent East | February 9, 1920† | James B. Clark | United Farmers of Ontario | Manning Doherty | United Farmers of Ontario | Resignation to provide a seat for Doherty | Yes | ||
Brant North | December 15, 1919† | Harry Nixon | United Farmers of Ontario | Harry Nixon | United Farmers of Ontario | Sought re-election upon appointment as Provincial Secretary and Registrar | Yes | ||
Wentworth North | December 15, 1919† | Frank Campbell Biggs | United Farmers of Ontario | Frank Campbell Biggs | United Farmers of Ontario | Sought re-election upon appointment as Minister of Public Works and Highways | Yes | ||
Perth South | December 15, 1919† | Peter Smith | United Farmers of Ontario | Peter Smith | United Farmers of Ontario | Sought re-election upon appointment as Provincial Treasurer | Yes | ||
Manitoulin | December 15, 1919† | Beniah Bowman | United Farmers of Ontario | Beniah Bowman | United Farmers of Ontario | Sought re-election upon appointment as Minister of Lands, Forests and Mines | Yes | ||
Hamilton West | December 15, 1919† | Walter Rollo | Labour | Walter Rollo | Labour | Sought re-election upon appointment as Minister of Labour | Yes | ||
Carleton | December 15, 1919† | Robert Henry Grant | United Farmers of Ontario | Robert Henry Grant | United Farmers of Ontario | Sought re-election upon appointment as Minister of Education | Yes |
† Won by acclamation
14th Legislative Assembly of Ontario 1914–1919
† Won by acclamation
13th Legislative Assembly of Ontario 1911–1914
By-election | Date | Incumbent | Party | Winner | Party | Cause | Retained | ||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Middlesex East | November 27, 1913 | George Wesley Neely | Conservative | John McFarlane | Conservative | Death | Yes | ||
Peel | November 3, 1913 | Samuel Charters | Conservative | James Robinson Fallis | Conservative | Appointed Registrar | Yes | ||
York East | September 8, 1913 | Alexander McCowan | Conservative | George Stewart Henry | Conservative | Appointed Sheriff of York County | Yes | ||
Grey North | July 14, 1913 | Alexander Grant MacKay | Liberal | Colin Stewart Cameron | Conservative | Resignation upon entering provincial politics in Alberta | No | ||
Grey Centre | June 2, 1913† | Isaac Benson Lucas | Conservative | Isaac Benson Lucas | Conservative | Sought re-election upon appointment as Provincial Treasurer | Yes | ||
Lanark South | March 19, 1913 | Arthur Matheson | Conservative | John Charles Ebbs | Conservative | Death | Yes | ||
Muskoka | November 5, 1912† | Arthur Arnold Mahaffy | Conservative | Samuel Henry Armstrong | Conservative | Appointed a Judge | Yes | ||
Waterloo North | October 28, 1912 | Henry George Lackner | Conservative | Charles Henry Mills | Conservative | Appointed Sheriff of Waterloo County | Yes | ||
Middlesex East | October 28, 1912 | Robert Sutherland | Liberal | George Wesley Neely | Conservative | Death | No |
† Won by acclamation
12th Legislative Assembly of Ontario 1908–1911
By-election | Date | Incumbent | Party | Winner | Party | Cause | Retained | ||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Wellington South | October 21, 1910† | Joseph Patrick Downey | Conservative | John Ransom Howitt | Conservative | Appointed Superintendent for the Ontario Asylum for Idiots | Yes | ||
Middlesex North | December 6, 1909 | Duncan Campbell Ross | Liberal | James William Doyle | Conservative | Resignation to enter federal politics | No | ||
Victoria East | May 25, 1909 | John Hilliard Carnegie | Conservative | Robert Mercer Mason | Conservative | Resignation upon appointment as Distributor of Law Stamps | Yes | ||
Algoma | December 17, 1908† | William Ross Smyth | Conservative | Albert Grigg | Conservative | Resignation to enter federal politics | Yes | ||
Simcoe West | October 23, 1908† | James Stoddart Duff | Conservative | James Stoddart Duff | Conservative | Sought re-election upon appointment as Minister of Agriculture | Yes |
† Won by acclamation
11th Legislative Assembly of Ontario 1905–1908
By-election | Date | Incumbent | Party | Winner | Party | Cause | Retained | ||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Brockville | October 7, 1907 | George Perry Graham | Liberal | Albert Edward Donovan | Conservative | Resignation on entering federal politics | No | ||
Dufferin | July 24, 1907 | Frederick William Lewis | Conservative | Charles Robert McKeown | Conservative | Death | Yes | ||
York West | June 1, 1907 | Joseph Wesley St. John | Conservative | Forbes Godfrey | Conservative | Death | Yes | ||
Carleton | March 18, 1907 | George Nelson Kidd | Conservative | Robert McElroy | Conservative | Death | Yes | ||
Middlesex West | February 20, 1907 | George William Ross | Liberal | Duncan Campbell Ross | Liberal | Appointed to the Senate | Yes | ||
Hamilton East | December 4, 1906 | Henry Carscallen | Conservative | Allan Studholme | Labour | Death | No | ||
Cardwell | September 21, 1906† | Edward Alfred Little | Conservative | Alexander Ferguson | Conservative | Appointed Registrar | Yes | ||
Toronto North | February 22, 1906 | William Beattie Nesbitt | Conservative | William Kirkpatrick McNaught | Conservative | Appointed registrar of West Toronto | Yes | ||
Kingston | January 29, 1906 | Edward John Barker Pense | Liberal | Edward John Barker Pense | Liberal | Election declared void | Yes | ||
Nipissing East | June 13, 1905† | Charles Lamarche | Conservative | Francis Cochrane | Conservative | Resignation to provide a seat for Cochrane | Yes | ||
Toronto South | February 21, 1905† | James Joseph Foy | Conservative | James Joseph Foy | Conservative | Sought re-election upon appointment as Commissioner of Crown Lands | Yes | ||
Toronto East | February 21, 1905† | Robert Allan Pyne | Conservative | Robert Allan Pyne | Conservative | Sought re-election upon appointment as Minister of Education | Yes | ||
Perth South | February 21, 1905† | Samuel Nelson Monteith | Conservative | Samuel Nelson Monteith | Conservative | Sought re-election upon appointment as Minister of Agriculture | Yes | ||
Lanark South | February 21, 1905† | Arthur James Matheson | Conservative | Arthur James Matheson | Conservative | Sought re-election upon appointment as Provincial Treasurer | Yes | ||
Lambton West | February 21, 1905† | William John Hanna | Conservative | William John Hanna | Conservative | Sought re-election upon appointment as Provincial Secretary and Registrar | Yes | ||
Essex North | February 21, 1905† | Joseph Octave Reaume | Conservative | Joseph Octave Reaume | Conservative | Sought re-election upon appointment as Commissioner of Public Works | Yes | ||
Dundas | February 21, 1905† | James Pliny Whitney | Conservative | James Pliny Whitney | Conservative | Sought re-election upon appointment as Premier and Attorney-General | Yes |
† Won by acclamation
10th Legislative Assembly of Ontario 1902–1904
By-election | Date | Incumbent | Party | Winner | Party | Cause | Retained | ||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Oxford North | January 26, 1904 | Andrew Pattulo | Liberal | James S. Munro | Liberal | Death | Yes | ||
Renfrew North | December 26, 1903 | John W. Munro | Liberal | Edward Arunah Dunlop | Conservative | Death | No | ||
Sault Ste. Marie | October 27, 1903 | Andrew Miscampbell | Conservative | Charles Napier Smith | Liberal | Void Election | No | ||
Muskoka | October 27, 1903 | Samuel Bridgeland | Liberal | Arthur Arnold Mahaffy | Conservative | Death | No | ||
York North | February 26, 1903 | Elihu James Davis | Liberal | Elihu James Davis | Liberal | Resignation in exchange for withdrawal of election petition | Yes | ||
Bruce Centre | February 26, 1903 | Hugh Clark | Conservative | Hugh Clark | Conservative | Void Election | Yes | ||
Perth North | January 7, 1903 | John C. Monteith | Conservative | John Brown | Liberal | Void Election | No | ||
Norfolk North | January 7, 1903 | Frederick S. Snider | Conservative | Archibald Little | Liberal | Void Election | No | ||
Grey North | January 7, 1903 | Alexander Grant MacKay | Liberal | Alexander Grant MacKay | Liberal | Void Election | Yes |
9th Legislative Assembly of Ontario 1898–1902
† Won by acclamation
8th Legislative Assembly of Ontario 1894–1898
By-election | Date | Incumbent | Party | Winner | Party | Cause | Retained | ||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Essex South | October 20, 1896 | William Douglas Balfour | Liberal | John Allan Auld | Liberal | Death | Yes | ||
York North | September 8, 1896† | Elihu James Davis | Liberal | Elihu James Davis | Liberal | Sought re-election upon appointment as Provincial Secretary and Registrar | Yes | ||
Oxford North | September 7, 1896 | Oliver Mowat | Liberal | Andrew Pattulo | Liberal | Appointed to the Senate | Yes | ||
Essex South | August 4, 1896† | William Douglas Balfour | Liberal | William Douglas Balfour | Liberal | Sought re-election upon appointment as Provincial Secretary and Registrar | Yes | ||
Wentworth South | January 24, 1896 | Nicholas Awrey | Liberal | John Dickenson | Liberal | Appointed Sheriff of Wentworth County | Yes | ||
Wellington West | January 24, 1896 | George Tucker | Conservative-PPA | James Tucker | Conservative | Void Election | Yes | ||
Kingston | October 8, 1895† | William Harty | Liberal | William Harty | Liberal | Void Election | Yes | ||
Brant North | May 20, 1895† | William Bruce Wood | Liberal | Daniel Burt | Liberal | Resignation | Yes | ||
Haldimand | March 19, 1895 | John Senn | Conservative | Jacob Baxter | Liberal | Void Election | No | ||
Algoma West | January 29, 1895 | James M. Savage | Conservative | James Conmee | Liberal | Void Election | No | ||
Kingston | January 28, 1895 | Edward H. Smythe | Conservative | William Harty | Liberal | Void Election | No | ||
London | November 20, 1894 | William Ralph Meredith | Conservative | Thomas Saunders Hobbs | Liberal | Appointed a judge | No |
† Won by acclamation
7th Legislative Assembly of Ontario 1890–1894
† Won by acclamation
6th Legislative Assembly of Ontario 1886–1890
† Won by acclamation
5th Legislative Assembly of Ontario 1883–1886
By-election | Date | Incumbent | Party | Winner | Party | Cause | Retained | ||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Algoma East | June 29, 1885 | New Seat | Robert Adam Lyon | Liberal | Algoma divided | N/A | |||
Simcoe East | June 26, 1885 | Charles Alfred Drury | Liberal | Charles Alfred Drury | Liberal | Void Election | Yes | ||
Lennox | June 26, 1885 | George Douglas Hawley | Liberal | George Douglas Hawley | Liberal | Void Election | Yes | ||
Algoma West | June 26, 1885 | New Seat | James Conmee | Liberal | Algoma divided | N/A | |||
Kent East | June 19, 1885† | Daniel McCraney | Liberal | Robert Ferguson | Liberal | Death | Yes | ||
Renfrew South | January 27, 1885 | John Francis Dowling | Liberal | John Francis Dowling | Liberal | Void Election | Yes | ||
Lennox | August 28, 1884 | Alexander Hall Roe | Conservative | George Douglas Hawley | Liberal | Death | No | ||
Muskoka and Parry Sound | July 23, 1884 | Frederick G. Fauquier | Conservative | Jacob William Dill | Liberal | Void Election | No | ||
Grey East | March 18, 1884 | Abram William Lauder | Conservative | Neil McColman | Conservative | Death | Yes | ||
Oxford South | March 5, 1884 | Adam Crooks | Liberal | George Atwell Cooke | Liberal | Crooks declared "incurably insane" and seat vacated | Yes | ||
Renfrew South | January 18, 1884 | John Francis Dowling | Liberal | John Francis Dowling | Liberal | Void Election | Yes | ||
Simcoe West | December 14, 1883 | Orson James Phelps | Liberal | Orson James Phelps | Liberal | Void Election | Yes | ||
Middlesex West | December 14, 1883 | Alexander Johnston | Conservative | George William Ross | Liberal | Void Election | No | ||
Cardwell | December 14, 1883 | William Henry Hammell | Conservative | William Henry Hammell | Conservative | Void Election | Yes | ||
Huron West | November 16, 1883† | Alexander McLagan Ross | Liberal | Alexander McLagan Ross | Liberal | Sought re-election upon appointment as Provincial Treasurer and Commissioner of Agriculture | Yes | ||
Brant North | June 16, 1883 | James Young | Liberal | James Young | Liberal | Sought re-election upon appointment as Provincial Treasurer and Commissioner of Agriculture | Yes |
† Won by acclamation
4th Legislative Assembly of Ontario 1879–1883
By-election | Date | Incumbent | Party | Winner | Party | Cause | Retained | ||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Muskoka and Parry Sound | October 30, 1882 | John Classon Miller | Liberal | James Whitney Bettes | Liberal | Resignation to contest the 1882 federal election | Yes | ||
Waterloo South | October 18, 1882 | James Livingston | Liberal | Isaac Master | Liberal | Resignation to contest the 1882 federal election | Yes | ||
Simcoe East | October 18, 1882 | Herman Henry Cook | Liberal | Charles Alfred Drury | Liberal | Resignation to contest the 1882 federal election | Yes | ||
Renfrew North | October 18, 1882† | Thomas Murray | Liberal | William Balmer McAllister | Conservative | Resignation to contest the 1882 federal election | Yes* | ||
Hastings West | October 18, 1882 | Alexander Robertson | Conservative | Baltis Rose | Conservative | Resignation to contest the 1882 federal election | Yes | ||
Glengarry | October 18, 1882 | Donald Macmaster | Conservative | James Rayside | Liberal | Resignation to contest the 1882 federal election | No | ||
Essex South | October 18, 1882 | Lewis Wigle | Conservative | William Douglas Balfour | Liberal | Resignation to contest the 1882 federal election | No | ||
Bruce South | October 18, 1882 | Rupert Mearse Wells | Liberal | Hamilton Parke O'Connor | Liberal | Resignation to contest the 1882 federal election | Yes | ||
Peterborough West | August 24, 1881† | William Hepburn Scott | Conservative | Robert Kincaid | Conservative | Death | Yes | ||
Durham East | June 29, 1881 | John Rosevear | Conservative | Charles Herbert Brereton | Conservative | Death | Yes | ||
Waterloo North | June 27, 1881 | Moses Springer | Liberal | Elias Weber Bingeman Snider | Liberal | Resignation to become Sheriff of Waterloo County | Yes | ||
Ontario North | June 4, 1881 | Thomas Paxton | Liberal | Frank Madill | Conservative | Resignation to become Sheriff of Ontario County | No | ||
Prescott | April 14, 1881 | William Harkin | Conservative | Albert Hagar | Liberal | Death | No | ||
Hastings West | January 30, 1880 | Alexander Robertson | Conservative | Alexander Robertson | Conservative | Void Election | Yes | ||
Stormont | January 23, 1880 | Joseph Kerr | Conservative | Joseph Kerr | Conservative | Void Election | Yes | ||
Dufferin | January 9, 1880 | John Barr | Conservative | William Jelly | Conservative | Void Election | Yes |
† Won by acclamation
*McAllister was a supporter of Mowat's government
3rd Legislative Assembly of Ontario 1875–1879
† Won by acclamation
2nd Legislative Assembly of Ontario 1871–1874
By-election | Date | Incumbent | Party | Winner | Party | Cause | Retained | ||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Peterborough West | July 30, 1874 | Thomas McCulloch Fairbairn | Liberal | William Hepburn Scott | Conservative | Death | No | ||
Wellington North | February 20, 1874 | Robert McKim | Liberal | John McGowan | Conservative | Resignation to enter federal politics | No | ||
Perth North | February 14, 1874 | Andrew Monteith | Conservative | Thomas Mayne Daly | Conservative | Resignation to enter federal politics | Yes | ||
Oxford South | January 19, 1874† | Adam Oliver | Liberal | Adam Oliver | Liberal | Resignation due to not being appointed Sheriff of Oxford County and selling timber to the provincial government | Yes | ||
Ottawa | January 18, 1874 | Richard William Scott | Liberal | Daniel John O'Donoghue | Independent Labour | Appointed to the Senate | Yes | ||
Simcoe South | December 30, 1873 | Thomas Roberts Ferguson | Conservative | D'Arcy Boulton | Conservative | Resignation | Yes | ||
Peel | December 19, 1873 | John Coyne | Conservative | Kenneth Chisholm | Liberal | Death | No | ||
Grenville South | December 9, 1873† | Christopher Finlay Fraser | Liberal | Christopher Finlay Fraser | Liberal | Sought re-election upon appointment as Provincial Secretary and Registrar | Yes | ||
Leeds South | December 1873† | Herbert Stone MacDonald | Conservative | John Godkin Giles | Conservative | Resignation to be appointed to the county court | Yes | ||
Huron South | October 16, 1873 | Robert Gibbons | Liberal | Archibald Bishop | Liberal | Resignation to become Sheriff of Huron County | Yes | ||
Brant South | April 28, 1873 | Edmund Burke Wood | Conservative | Arthur Sturgis Hardy | Liberal | Resignation to enter federal politics | No | ||
Oxford North | November 29, 1872† | George Perry | Liberal | Oliver Mowat | Liberal | Resignation to provide a seat for Mowat | Yes | ||
Lambton | November 13, 1872† | Timothy Blair Pardee | Liberal | Timothy Blair Pardee | Liberal | Sought re-election upon appointment as Provincial Secretary and Registrar | Yes | ||
Grenville South | October 16, 1872 | Christopher Finlay Fraser | Liberal | Christopher Finlay Fraser | Liberal | Void Election | Yes | ||
Middlesex West | September 17, 1872 | Alexander Mackenzie | Liberal | John Watterworth | Liberal | Resignation upon abolition of the dual mandate | Yes | ||
Bruce South | September 14, 1872 | Edward Blake | Liberal | Rupert Mearse Wells | Liberal | Resignation upon abolition of the dual mandate | Yes | ||
Monck | September 1872 | Lachlin McCallum | Conservative | Henry Ryan Haney | Liberal | Resignation upon abolition of the dual mandate | No | ||
London | August 26, 1872 | John Carling | Conservative | William Ralph Meredith | Conservative | Resignation upon abolition of the dual mandate | Yes | ||
Lanark North | August 23, 1872 | Daniel Galbraith | Liberal | William Clyde Caldwell | Liberal | Resignation to enter federal politics | Yes | ||
Cornwall | July 13, 1872 | John Sandfield Macdonald | Conservative | John Goodall Snetsinger | Liberal | Death | No | ||
Grenville South | March 26, 1872 | Mcneil Clarke | Conservative | Christopher Finlay Fraser | Liberal | Death | No | ||
Toronto West | January 9, 1872 | Adam Crooks | Liberal | Adam Crooks | Liberal | Sought re-election upon appointment as Attorney-General | Yes | ||
Bothwell | January 6, 1872† | Archibald McKellar | Liberal | Archibald McKellar | Liberal | Sought re-election upon appointment as Commissioner of Agriculture and Public Works | Yes | ||
Middlesex West | January 5, 1872† | Alexander Mackenzie | Liberal | Alexander Mackenzie | Liberal | Sought re-election upon appointment as Provincial Secretary and Registrar | Yes | ||
Bruce South | January 5, 1872† | Edward Blake | Liberal | Edward Blake | Liberal | Resignation to re-contest upon being appointed Premier | Yes | ||
Northumberland West | January 5, 1872 | Alexander Fraser | Liberal | Charles Gifford | Conservative | Resignation | No | ||
Wellington South | January 4, 1872† | Peter Gow | Liberal | Peter Gow | Liberal | Sought re-election upon appointment as Provincial Secretary and Registrar | Yes | ||
Ottawa | January 4, 1872† | Richard William Scott | Liberal | Richard William Scott | Liberal | Sought re-election upon appointment as Commissioner of Crown Lands | Yes | ||
Stormont | January 3, 1872 | William Colquhoun | Conservative | James Bethune | Liberal | Void Election | No | ||
Simcoe North | January 2, 1872 | William Davis Ardagh | Conservative | William Davis Ardagh | Conservative | Void Election | Yes | ||
Carleton | January 2, 1872 | George William Monk | Conservative | George William Monk | Conservative | Void Election | Yes | ||
Prince Edward | December 29, 1871 | Gideon Striker | Liberal | James Simeon McCuaig | Conservative | Void Election | No | ||
James Simeon McCuaig | Conservative | Gideon Striker | Liberal | By-election result reversed August 29, 1872 | No | ||||
Grey South | December 29, 1871 | Abram William Lauder | Conservative | Abram William Lauder | Conservative | Void Election | Yes | ||
Prescott | December 27, 1871† | George Wellesley Hamilton | Conservative | George Wellesley Hamilton | Conservative | Void Election | Yes | ||
Durham West | December 27, 1871† | Edward Blake | Liberal | John McLeod | Liberal | Chose to sit for Bruce South | Yes |
† Won by acclamation
1st Legislative Assembly of Ontario 1867–1871
By-election | Date | Incumbent | Party | Winner | Party | Cause | Retained | ||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Prince Edward | June 29, 1870 | Absalom Greeley | Liberal | William Anderson | Conservative | Appointed Sheriff of Prince Edward County | No | ||
Renfrew North | December 1, 1869 | John Supple | Conservative | Thomas Murray | Liberal | Resignation | No | ||
Lanark South | February 3–4, 1869 | William McNairn Shaw | Conservative | Abraham Code | Conservative | Death | Yes | ||
Frontenac | October 19, 1868 | Henry Smith | Conservative | Delino Dexter Calvin | Conservative | Death | Yes | ||
Niagara | December 1867 | Donald Robertson | Conservative | Stephen Richards | Conservative | Appointed Coroner | Yes |
References
Notes
Citations
- "These Are Men In Vote Race For One Seat". Windsor Star. September 9, 1964.
- "Ontario Grits, C.C.F. Shun 2 By-elections". Windsor Star. August 29, 1958.
Further reading
- Forman, Debra Legislators and Legislatures of Ontario: A Reference Guide. Legislative Library of Ontario Research and Information Services, 1984
- Lewis, Roderick, Centennial Edition of a History of the Electoral Districts, Legislatures and Ministries of the Province of Ontario 1867–1968. F. Fogg, Queen's Printer, 1969.
- Electoral history of Ontario: Candidates and Results. Office of the Chief Election Officer of Ontario, 1983